NEMT Entrepreneur provides expert insights, strategies, and resources to help non-emergency medical transportation professionals grow their businesses. Get industry-leading advice to succeed in NEMT.
Featured articles
Choosing between a stretcher and a gurney for your Non-Emergency Medical Transportation (NEMT) business depends on factors like patient needs, trip length, and vehicle compatibility. Here’s a quick overview:
- Stretchers: Lightweight, portable, and budget-friendly. Ideal for short trips and tight spaces but require two caregivers for operation.
- Gurneys: Wheeled, adjustable, and designed for patient comfort. Best for long distances and patients needing constant monitoring, but they’re costlier and require vehicle modifications.
Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | Stretchers | Gurneys |
|---|---|---|
| Mobility | Manual carrying | Wheeled for easy movement |
| Staff Requirements | 2 caregivers | 1 trained operator |
| Distance Suitability | Short distances | Long distances |
| Patient Comfort | Basic support | Adjustable features |
| Cost | $200–$1,000 | $1,000–$5,000 |
| Vehicle Fit | Minimal modifications | Extensive modifications |
Key Takeaway: Use stretchers for short-distance, low-cost operations and gurneys for long-distance trips requiring safety and comfort. Assess your fleet, budget, and patient needs to decide.
Stretchers vs. Gurneys: What You Need to Know
What Are Stretchers?
Stretchers are portable devices designed for moving patients over short distances. They usually consist of a sturdy canvas stretched over a rigid frame. These are lightweight and easy to maneuver in tight spaces but require at least two caregivers to carry safely due to their manual operation.
What Are Gurneys?
Gurneys are wheeled patient transport devices equipped with adjustable features like side rails and locking mechanisms for added safety. Their design allows a single trained professional to move patients securely, and they can accommodate individuals of varying sizes. Gurneys are built for smooth transportation and offer more support compared to stretchers.
How Stretchers and Gurneys Differ
The choice between stretchers and gurneys depends on the specific needs of each transport scenario. Here's a breakdown of their key differences:
| Feature | Stretchers | Gurneys |
|---|---|---|
| Mobility | Requires manual carrying | Equipped with wheels for ease |
| Operator Needs | At least 2 caregivers | Single professional |
| Distance Suitability | Best for short distances | Designed for longer distances |
| Patient Support | Basic support | Adjustable features for comfort |
| Storage | Compact and collapsible | Larger, fixed structure |
| Safety Features | Basic restraints | Includes side rails and locks |
For Non-Emergency Medical Transport (NEMT) providers, these differences play a big role in decisions about vehicle setup, staffing, and patient safety. Stretchers are great for quick, short-distance transfers and fit easily in various vehicles without major adjustments. Gurneys, on the other hand, are better for long-distance transport, offering more stability and comfort but requiring specialized vehicles to accommodate their size and weight.
When deciding which option fits your NEMT needs, consider the type of transport you handle most often. Gurneys are ideal for efficiency and patient comfort during longer trips, while stretchers excel in versatility and ease of storage [2]. Knowing these distinctions helps ensure you’re making the best choice for your operations and patient care.
Patient Transport: Transporting a Patient on a Stretcher
Functionality: Which Option Works Best for You?
Choosing the right equipment for your NEMT business is all about functionality - it directly affects patient care and how smoothly your team operates.
Patient Safety and Comfort
Gurneys are designed with patient safety and comfort in mind. They come with adjustable features like headrests and support pads, making them perfect for patients who need constant care or must remain flat, such as those undergoing dialysis or dealing with spinal injuries [2]. Their wheeled design ensures stable and smooth transport, reducing discomfort and minimizing risks during transfers [3].
Ease of Use for Staff
Gurneys can be operated by a single professional, which boosts staff efficiency. On the other hand, stretchers require two caregivers, which can be a challenge during busy times. However, stretchers are lighter and easier to maintain, offering their own advantages.
Comparison Table: Features of Stretchers and Gurneys
| Feature | Stretchers | Gurneys |
|---|---|---|
| Patient Positioning | Basic flat position | Multiple adjustable positions |
| Safety Features | Basic restraints | Advanced restraints, side rails, locks |
| Staff Requirements | Minimum 2 operators | Single trained operator |
| Patient Transfer | Best for short distances | Suitable for long distances |
| Comfort Features | Basic padding | Adjustable headrests, support pads |
When deciding, think about your typical patients and transport needs. Gurneys are often better for long-distance medical appointments, while stretchers work well in tighter spaces or for short-distance transfers [1][2].
Functionality is just one aspect to consider - up next, we'll dive into costs and operational efficiency to help you make a well-rounded decision.
sbb-itb-cef70f4
Costs and Efficiency: What to Consider
Upfront and Maintenance Costs
Stretchers are generally more affordable, with prices ranging from $200 to $1,000, while gurneys are priced higher, between $1,000 and $5,000, thanks to their added features and durability [2].
When it comes to maintenance, stretchers are simpler to manage. They typically require basic cleaning and occasional checks. On the other hand, gurneys come with higher upkeep costs due to their moving parts. For instance, replacing gurney wheels can cost over $100 and may need to be done annually or even more often, depending on usage [2].
Impact on Operations
Stretchers and gurneys influence both daily workflows and long-term expenses in different ways. While gurneys have a steeper upfront cost, they can save up to 20% in labor expenses since they only need one operator [2]. Stretchers, however, are easier to integrate with standard vehicles, keeping operational costs lower. Over time, the efficiency of gurneys might offset the added expense of modifying vehicles.
Cost Comparison Table: Stretchers vs. Gurneys
| Cost Factor | Stretchers | Gurneys |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase Price | $200 - $1,000 | $1,000 - $5,000 |
| Annual Maintenance | Low (basic cleaning) | Moderate to High |
| Staff Requirements | 2+ operators needed | 1 operator needed |
| Vehicle Modification | Minimal or none | Extensive modifications |
| Long-term Labor Costs | Higher (multiple staff) | 30% lower (single operator) |
| Storage Requirements | Minimal | Requires dedicated space |
When deciding, think about your business's workload and the distances you typically cover. For instance, if long-distance trips are common, the higher upfront cost of gurneys might be worth it for the savings in labor and smoother operations over time [2]. Lower labor costs not only boost profitability but also free up staff to provide better patient care, improving service quality overall.
These considerations are key to choosing the right option for your NEMT business, which we'll delve into further in the next section.
How to Choose the Right Equipment for Your Business
Key Factors to Consider
When selecting transport equipment, focus on what your patients need and how your service operates. For instance, if you often transport bedridden patients or those needing constant monitoring, gurneys might be a better option. They offer added comfort with features like adjustable headrests and support pads [1].
Gurneys can also reduce staffing demands since they can be operated by one person, unlike stretchers, which usually require two operators. For long-distance trips, gurneys provide better stability and safety but come with a higher initial cost [2].
Matching Equipment to Your Vehicles
Don't overlook vehicle compatibility - it’s a critical factor. Here’s a quick guide:
| Vehicle Type | Recommended Equipment | Required Modifications |
|---|---|---|
| Standard Van | Stretchers | Minimal modifications |
| Modified Vehicle | Gurneys | Extensive securing systems |
| Mixed Fleet | Combination approach | Vehicle-specific setup |
Take JAX NEMT as an example: They paired their transport equipment with their fleet's specifications, using a mix of stretchers and gurneys. This approach allowed them to stay flexible while keeping patients safe [3]. Ensuring your equipment matches your vehicles not only improves efficiency but also enhances patient care.
Tips for Making the Best Choice
After aligning your equipment with your fleet, it’s time to assess operational needs and put the equipment to the test. Here’s how:
- Evaluate patient needs and ensure vehicle compatibility, including any necessary modifications.
- Calculate overall costs, factoring in both the purchase price and ongoing operational expenses.
Then, test the equipment in practical scenarios to check:
- How easy it is to load and unload.
- Patient comfort during transport.
- Staff efficiency and safety.
- How well it fits with your vehicles.
These steps will help you make an informed decision, ensuring both operational efficiency and high-quality patient care.
Conclusion: Making the Best Choice for Your NEMT Business
Key Points to Remember
Stretchers are lightweight, easy to store, and great for short trips or emergency situations. Their portability makes them a practical option for quick deployment [1].
Gurneys, while more expensive, come with features like adjustable headrests and powered wheels. These additions are especially helpful for patients needing constant monitoring or those with limited mobility [2].
As discussed earlier, stretchers are budget-friendly and suitable for shorter distances, while gurneys offer greater comfort and efficiency, particularly for longer trips and scenarios where staffing can be minimized.
Practical Tips
Pick the solution that best fits your NEMT business by weighing comfort, cost, and efficiency. Focus on these three areas:
- Patient Needs: Consider the medical conditions and mobility challenges of those you transport.
- Routes and Distances: Assess whether your service involves short or long-distance trips.
- Investment Costs: Factor in the purchase price, upkeep, and any operational expenses.
Also, think about your fleet's capabilities. Stretchers usually fit standard vehicles, but gurneys might need specialized adjustments [2]. Matching your equipment to your service model is key to running an effective operation.
FAQs
Deciding between a stretcher and a gurney can feel overwhelming, but knowing their differences makes it easier. Below are answers to common questions to help guide your choice.
What is the difference between a stretcher and a gurney?
Stretchers are lightweight and portable, requiring manual carrying. Gurneys, on the other hand, come with wheels and extra features for easier mobility and functionality [1].
How do I choose between a stretcher and a gurney for my NEMT service?
Keep these three factors in mind when making your decision:
- Patient Needs: Think about whether your patients require constant monitoring or have mobility challenges [2].
- Trip Length: Stretchers are better for short distances, while gurneys are ideal for longer trips [1].
- Vehicle Fit: Make sure the equipment works with your vehicle's size and storage capacity [2].
What are the cost considerations for each?
Gurneys might save money in the long run by reducing staff workload and maintenance costs [2][4]. Stretchers are cheaper upfront but need more staff involvement and upkeep.
How do these options impact efficiency?
Gurneys help by easing the physical demands on staff, while stretchers are lighter and take up less space [1][2].
What safety measures should I consider?
Both options require strict attention to safety. Here’s what to focus on:
- Staff Training: Ensure your team knows how to use the equipment properly.
- Routine Maintenance: Regularly inspect and maintain the equipment.
- Vehicle Fit: Confirm that the mounting systems are secure.
- Patient Needs: Match the equipment to the specific requirements of each patient [2].
Are there other options worth exploring?
Yes, specialized transport wheelchairs can be an alternative [4]. These might be a good fit depending on your service model and patient needs.
