NEMT Entrepreneur provides expert insights, strategies, and resources to help non-emergency medical transportation professionals grow their businesses. Get industry-leading advice to succeed in NEMT.
Featured articles
Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare are reshaping the Non-Emergency Medical Transportation (NEMT) landscape. These rideshare platforms focus on low-acuity, ambulatory trips, offering healthcare providers tools to manage patient transportation efficiently. Both integrate with Electronic Health Records (EHR) systems and provide HIPAA-compliant dashboards, enabling care coordinators to schedule rides for patients without smartphones.
Key Highlights:
- Uber Health: Offers ambulatory, wheelchair-accessible rides, prescription delivery, and multilingual support. It partners with brokers and health plans for Medicaid services.
- Lyft Healthcare: Operates as a Medicaid provider in 21 states, features Lyft Assisted (door-to-door support), and emphasizes cost reduction with tools like Lyft Pass.
Both platforms can complement existing NEMT services by handling low-acuity rides, allowing providers to focus on patients with complex needs. However, they lack specialized medical training for drivers and equipment for high-acuity care. Providers can integrate these platforms into their systems to improve efficiency during peak demand while addressing transportation barriers.
| Feature | Uber Health | Lyft Healthcare |
|---|---|---|
| NEMT Assistance | Wheelchair-accessible, door-to-door rides | Lyft Assisted (light physical support) |
| Delivery Services | Prescriptions, groceries, OTC items | Transportation only |
| Medicaid Status | Works with brokers, health plans | Enrolled provider in 21 states |
| Language Support | Over 15 languages | Not specified |
| Scheduling Options | On-demand, advance, recurring rides | On-demand, scheduled rides |
These platforms offer flexible solutions for healthcare providers, but their effectiveness depends on local market conditions and patient needs.
Uber as a Healthcare Company: The 'Rideshare in Healthcare' State-of-Play | Dan Trigub, Uber Health
What Uber Health Offers
Uber Health is a HIPAA-enabled platform designed to coordinate patient transportation via text or phone, supporting over 15 languages. Through a centralized dashboard, care coordinators can arrange on-demand, scheduled, or recurring rides, all with real-time tracking and proactive notifications. For instance, coordinators receive alerts if a driver is delayed or if a patient misses their pickup. Costs are incurred only for completed rides, and flexible payment options are available. This system provides a solid foundation for exploring Uber Health's standout features and partnerships within the healthcare sector.
Main Features of Uber Health
Uber Health offers a range of transportation options tailored to different patient needs, including standard ambulatory rides and specialized services for those with mobility challenges. Here’s a quick breakdown:
- UberX: Designed for ambulatory patients who can independently get in and out of vehicles.
- Uber Comfort: Features newer vehicles with extra legroom and longer driver wait times, ideal for patients who need additional time to board.
- Uber WAV: Provides wheelchair-accessible vehicles equipped with ramps. This service is currently available in cities like Boston, Philadelphia, Chicago, Washington D.C., New York City, Portland, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Austin, Houston, and Phoenix.
For patients requiring more assistance, the platform also offers Third-Party NEMT (Non-Emergency Medical Transportation). This service provides door-to-door support through healthcare transportation specialists. These rides must be booked at least 24 hours in advance and feature upfront pricing based on provider fees, rather than dynamic pricing. However, cancellation fees apply if trips are canceled within two hours of the scheduled pickup.
NEMT providers can integrate Uber Health's API into their dispatch software, simplifying ride management and aligning it with existing workflows. As Stan Vashovsky, CEO of Ambulnz, highlights:
"This portal allows the patients' needs to be addressed accurately and efficiently while keeping us organized and streamlined. [Plus], the integration of the Ambulnz platform with hospital electronic health records further streamlines the requesting, information-gathering, payment, and dispatch process."
Additionally, Uber Health's dashboard provides detailed reports on ride activity and spending, helping organizations better manage their budgets.
Healthcare Provider Partnerships
Uber Health's capabilities have enabled it to partner with a variety of healthcare organizations, including hospitals and behavioral health networks. For instance, Boston Medical Center uses Uber Health to ensure patients can attend critical appointments. Pediatric hematologist and medical oncologist Amy Sobota emphasized the platform's role in maintaining continuity of care.
Similarly, Coordinated Behavioral Care has adopted Uber Health to improve access to mental health services. Barry Granek, Vice President of Systems of Care, remarked:
"Uber Health helps members reduce hour-long train rides to just 20-minute car rides, making it more likely for members to make those appointments while simultaneously helping remove some of the burden."
These partnerships address a significant issue: transportation barriers. Each year, approximately 6 million Americans miss medical appointments due to transportation challenges, leading to an estimated $150 billion in economic losses.
What Lyft Healthcare Offers
Lyft Healthcare operates as a B2B platform within the Medicaid Non-Emergency Medical Transportation (NEMT) network, spanning 21 states and serving over 62% of Medicaid beneficiaries. As a recognized provider in these networks, Lyft Healthcare integrates seamlessly with brokers and healthcare organizations through Lyft Concierge - a web-based tool that schedules rides for patients, even those without smartphones or the Lyft app. Ride details are shared via text or landline, ensuring accessibility for all patients. This setup simplifies the transportation process for healthcare providers and patients alike.
By focusing on low-acuity, ambulatory rides, Lyft Healthcare has reduced costs by 32%. A notable example of its success is in Tennessee, where TennCare, the state’s Medicaid agency, granted Lyft Healthcare permanent statewide authorization in January 2023 after a successful pilot program launched in 2019 to address transportation gaps.
Main Services of Lyft Healthcare
Lyft Healthcare delivers four key services tailored to meet diverse operational needs:
- Lyft Concierge: A tool that lets care coordinators book and monitor rides in real time.
- Lyft Assisted: This door-to-door service features drivers trained through a specialized tutorial developed with the Open Doors Organization (ODO).
- Lyft Pass: Enables organizations to subsidize rides for patients or staff, with built-in controls for budgets, destinations, and timeframes. For instance, following Hurricane Ian in October 2022, Lee Health used Lyft Pass to provide transportation for employees who had lost personal vehicles.
- Medicaid Integration: Lyft partners with existing NEMT infrastructure to streamline services.
ChenMed, a senior-focused primary care provider, rolled out Lyft Assisted across several markets between 2022 and 2023. The results were impressive: a 20% reduction in patient no-shows and a significant boost in transportation satisfaction scores, as noted by Dr. Nehal Gheewala, National Director of Growth:
"Lyft Assisted has boosted our patients' satisfaction with transportation tremendously. Our transportation survey score has increased from the 80's to above 90 in the markets where we have Lyft Assisted, which is a huge success."
Similarly, SafeRide Health incorporated Lyft’s flexible ride network into its NEMT management platform, cutting patient no-show rates by 63% and reducing call center volume by 30%. The platform also offers detailed reporting tools, simplifying budget management and insurance data submission for NEMT providers.
Technology and Accessibility Features
Lyft Healthcare’s technology integrates directly into Electronic Health Records (EHR), care management systems, and NEMT broker platforms through its API. This integration allows providers to schedule rides without leaving their existing workflows, making the process more efficient. Lyft partners with the largest U.S. health systems and NEMT brokers, including Modivcare and SafeRide Health. For example, LogistiCare (now Modivcare) entered a three-year nationwide partnership with Lyft in 2017, using the API to serve 27 million riders across 31 states.
The Lyft Concierge dashboard offers real-time ride tracking and automated notifications. It has proven popular, with 83% of older adult riders becoming repeat users after their first trip. Additionally, Business Profiles enable healthcare staff to bill work-related transportation expenses directly to their organization for easier financial management.
Accessibility is a priority for Lyft Healthcare. The Lyft Assisted service is approved for Medicaid beneficiaries in Florida and Delaware and available in select commercial markets, boasting an average satisfaction rating of 4.99 stars. Shana Hazan, Senior Director at On the Go, highlighted the platform’s reliability:
"The Lyft Concierge model has proven successful. We have an incredibly low rider-driver missed connection rate at around 3%. And we know that 83% of our older adult riders take more than one ride."
With a network of over 2 million drivers nationwide, Lyft Healthcare provides scalable capacity, especially during peak times. Its scheduling tools also allow coordinators to arrange return rides immediately after appointments, reducing the risk of patients being stranded and increasing trip completion rates.
sbb-itb-cef70f4
Uber Health vs. Lyft Healthcare: Feature Comparison
Uber Health vs Lyft Healthcare: Complete Feature Comparison for NEMT Providers
Side-by-Side Feature Comparison
Both Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare offer HIPAA-enabled APIs, no-app booking options, and EHR integration, but they diverge when it comes to service offerings and accessibility. Uber Health goes beyond transportation by including prescription delivery through ScriptDrop and grocery/OTC item delivery via Uber Eats, all managed from a single dashboard. Lyft Healthcare, on the other hand, focuses solely on patient and staff transportation, with features like Lyft Pass, which allows organizations to subsidize rides using built-in budget controls.
Lyft Healthcare includes Lyft Assisted, a service where standard drivers provide light physical support, such as offering an arm or elbow, and door-to-door assistance. Uber Health offers ambulatory rides through UberX and Comfort, along with specialized wheelchair-accessible rides provided by third-party credentialed drivers. Additionally, Uber Health supports patient communications in over 15 languages, while Lyft Healthcare's documentation does not specify multilingual capabilities.
Medicaid strategies also differ between the two. Lyft operates as an enrolled Medicaid provider in 21 states, while Uber Health collaborates with brokers and health plans. Pricing structures vary as well, with Uber Health using dynamic and upfront pricing, while Lyft's approach reportedly delivers a 32% cost reduction for its partners.
| Feature | Uber Health | Lyft Healthcare |
|---|---|---|
| NEMT Assistance | Specialized drivers for wheelchair-accessible, door-to-door service | Lyft Assisted (light door-to-door help by standard drivers) |
| Delivery Services | Prescriptions, groceries, and OTC items | Passenger transportation only |
| Medicaid Status | Works with brokers and health plans | Enrolled provider in 21 states |
| Language Support | Communicates with patients in over 15 languages | Not specified |
| Scheduling | On-demand, up to 30 days advance, and recurring rides | On-demand and scheduled rides |
This comparison highlights how each platform's unique features cater to different aspects of NEMT operations.
Pros and Cons for NEMT Providers
Expanding on the feature comparison, each platform offers distinct advantages and challenges for NEMT providers.
Uber Health's dashboard simplifies management by consolidating transportation, prescription deliveries, and grocery orders into one interface. Real-time intervention alerts notify coordinators if there are delays or missed pickups, enabling prompt action. However, standard Uber drivers generally lack medical training or CPR certification. Additionally, privacy controls mean drivers are not always informed their ride is for a medical purpose, which can leave them unprepared for frail or high-needs passengers.
Lyft Healthcare’s Medicaid enrollment in 21 states streamlines billing by reducing reliance on intermediaries like brokers. The platform also integrates with major NEMT brokers and U.S. health systems, offering broad compatibility. For instance, SafeRide Health reported a 63% drop in no-shows and a 30% reduction in call center volume after integrating Lyft’s network. However, rideshare platforms, in general, can experience higher failed pickup rates compared to traditional NEMT services. Additionally, Lyft Assisted training is conducted online, which some experts argue may not adequately prepare drivers for handling complex patient needs.
Yochai Eisenberg, Assistant Professor at the University of Illinois Hospital & Health Sciences System, pointed out:
"The lower cost is taking away in some way from the quality that traditional transportation companies can provide."
Both platforms are well-suited for low-acuity, ambulatory patients, allowing NEMT providers to allocate their specialized fleets for higher-acuity trips that require medical intervention. As Stan Vashovsky, CEO of Ambulnz, explained:
"This portal allows the patients' needs to be addressed accurately and efficiently while keeping us organized and streamlined."
How NEMT Providers Can Work with Rideshare Platforms
Using Rideshare for Ambulatory Patients
NEMT providers can optimize their resources by assigning ambulatory patients to rideshare platforms, freeing up specialized vehicles for clients with more complex needs. This approach ensures wheelchair-accessible and stretcher-equipped vehicles are available for high-priority trips, improving overall service efficiency.
For example, the U.S. Veterans Health Administration revealed that 83% of veterans would have missed their medical appointments without rides arranged through Uber Health over a two-year period. Similarly, OneWell Health Care reported monthly savings of $407 per participant by integrating Uber Health into their care plans.
Managing Peak Demand with Rideshare
Rideshare platforms also help NEMT providers handle peak demand effectively. During rush hours, last-minute requests, or when fleets are fully booked, these platforms offer a flexible solution. Instead of risking missed Service Level Agreements, providers can dispatch overflow rides through rideshare services without the need to expand their vehicle fleet or hire additional drivers.
This strategy not only reduces wait times by 30% to 34% but can also cut transportation costs by 20% to 40%, as it eliminates rush fees and caps wait times. SafeRide Health, for instance, saw a 63% decrease in no-shows and a 30% drop in call center volume after integrating Lyft's network into their operations. This model is particularly effective in congested urban areas, where traditional vehicles often face delays and rack up "deadhead" miles between trips.
Integrating Rideshare Technology
To maximize these advantages, integrating rideshare technology into existing NEMT systems is essential. Platforms like Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare offer API integrations that allow seamless rideshare dispatching within current NEMT software, boosting capacity without disrupting established workflows. Centralized dashboards provide real-time tracking and alerts, enabling coordinators to address delays before they lead to missed appointments.
Additionally, reporting tools monitor usage and spending, while GPS tracking and digital metrics confirm trip completion, helping to reduce fraud, waste, and abuse. For patients with limited English proficiency, Uber Health offers support in over 15 languages, breaking down communication barriers and making services more accessible.
Conclusion
Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare serve as effective complements to traditional Non-Emergency Medical Transportation (NEMT) by focusing on low-acuity, ambulatory trips. These platforms excel in handling such rides, freeing up specialized fleets for patients requiring wheelchairs, stretchers, or higher levels of care.
Uber Health stands out with its coordinator-led model and additional services like prescription and grocery delivery. On the other hand, Lyft Healthcare emphasizes patient independence through features like the Lyft Pass and its Medicaid partnerships in 21 states, achieving average cost savings of 32%.
As highlighted earlier, these platforms offer operational advantages. Many NEMT providers utilize rideshare services for overflow capacity. By integrating Uber Health or Lyft Healthcare APIs into their dispatch systems, providers can expand their capacity during peak times without adding vehicles or drivers.
To maximize efficiency, providers should segment patients based on their needs - assigning ambulatory trips to these platforms while reserving specialized resources for patients with higher requirements. Real-time dashboards can further aid in managing appointments and avoiding missed trips.
The decision to adopt these platforms often depends on local market conditions. Urban areas benefit from abundant drivers and quicker response times, whereas rural regions may face challenges with coverage. Before committing, providers should test the platforms' sandbox environments to ensure smooth integration with their current workflows. Additionally, given that rideshare drivers typically lack medical training, it’s essential to confirm that patients don’t require physical assistance beyond what "Uber Assist" or "Lyft Assisted" modes can provide.
Rather than viewing these platforms as competition, NEMT providers can use them strategically. Delegating low-acuity rides to Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare allows providers to focus their resources on delivering specialized, high-value services, ultimately improving operational efficiency and profitability.
FAQs
How do Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare work with existing NEMT systems?
Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare work hand-in-hand with existing Non-Emergency Medical Transportation (NEMT) systems through API solutions and platform integrations designed to fit smoothly into current workflows.
Uber Health's API connects NEMT providers to its vast driver network, offering features like real-time ride dispatch, trip tracking, and capacity management - all without disrupting daily operations. This allows organizations to expand their service areas, optimize processes, and meet service level agreements more effectively.
Similarly, Lyft Healthcare offers integration tools that enable providers to request and manage rides directly within their existing systems. Their platform supports Medicaid NEMT services, helping to reduce operational headaches while ensuring patients have dependable transportation options. Both platforms aim to simplify workflows, provide flexibility, and improve patient access to care through reliable and efficient transportation solutions.
What sets Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare apart for NEMT providers?
Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare take distinct approaches to non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT), focusing on different priorities to address patient and provider needs.
Uber Health stands out for its HIPAA-compliant platform that integrates directly into healthcare systems. With features like real-time ride scheduling and tracking, it allows providers to manage transportation effortlessly through a centralized dashboard or API. Patients don’t even need the Uber app, making it a streamlined option for reducing missed appointments.
Lyft Healthcare, however, places a stronger emphasis on partnerships with healthcare organizations. By weaving ride-sharing into broader healthcare benefit plans, it tackles social barriers to care while aiming to cut overall healthcare expenses. This approach highlights accessibility and affordability as key goals.
In short, Uber Health focuses on technology solutions for providers, while Lyft Healthcare prioritizes collaboration and cost-efficiency. Both platforms enhance access to care but follow unique strategies to support NEMT services.
Can Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare handle transportation for patients with complex medical needs?
Rideshare services like Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare are stepping into the healthcare space, offering dependable options for many non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) needs. They’re a solid choice for general healthcare trips, providing convenience and accessibility for patients who don’t require specialized care.
However, for patients with higher medical needs - think those requiring wheelchair-accessible vehicles or specialized equipment - these platforms face limitations. Traditional NEMT providers are better equipped for such cases, often offering trained drivers and vehicles tailored to handle complex medical situations.
In short, while Uber Health and Lyft Healthcare work well for routine medical transportation, high-acuity patients are still best served by NEMT providers specifically designed to meet those unique challenges.
