

The operator's publication for non-emergency medical transportation. State licensing guides, broker intel, a 2,000+ provider directory and The Dispatch, our weekly newsletter.
NEMT insurance is expensive because you are buying into a line that has lost money for over a decade, carrying passengers who are often elderly or disabled, in vans that run all day, usually with too little loss history to argue your own case. Commercial auto has posted 13 consecutive years of underwriting losses, and broker contracts ask for limits well above any state minimum. You cannot change the market. You can change most of what an underwriter sees about you, and that is worth more than another round of quotes.
This piece is the why. For coverage lines, required limits by state and current price ranges, see our NEMT insurance guide.
The combined ratio is losses plus expenses as a share of premium. Above 100, the insurer paid out more than it took in. Commercial auto ran a 103.5 combined ratio in 2025 while the property and casualty industry as a whole ran 95, according to AM Best. The liability side alone posted 113 in 2024 and has been above 100 every year since 2014. AM Best also estimates the line is under-reserved by $4 billion to $5 billion: losses already owed but not yet booked.
Conning counts 55 straight quarters of rate increases in commercial auto, and the line still loses money. That is why a clean year does not guarantee a flat renewal: part of your premium is your share of an industry problem.
2026 makes the gap obvious. The Council of Insurance Agents and Brokers' Q2 2026 market survey found commercial premiums fell an average of 2.0% across all account sizes, while umbrella rose 5.3% and commercial auto rose 4.5%, the two lines that went up, per Insurance Journal's summary. Over the same stretch, the consumer price index for personal motor vehicle insurance was down 5.1% in the 12 months to August 2026. If your own car renewal dropped and your fleet renewal climbed, both are accurate.
More of this business now runs through the excess and surplus lines market, where commercial auto liability premium grew 29.1% year over year through mid-2025, per AM Best.
The pressure comes from severity, the size of each claim. Conning puts commercial auto claim severity up 64% since 2015 and names social inflation and nuclear verdicts as the cause.
A small fleet rarely sees a verdict like that, but it pays for them. CIAB's Q2 survey names nuclear verdicts tied to commercial auto accidents as a main source of difficulty for umbrella, meaning lower limits and less capacity, and umbrella is the layer your broker contract makes you buy. AM Best adds that claims are taking longer to resolve, which gives each one more time to grow.
Of the 3.2 million Medicaid NEMT users in FY 2018, about two thirds were eligible on the basis of age or disability, per MACPAC. CMS's report to Congress found the heaviest users include members with end-stage renal disease, substance use disorders, intellectual or developmental disabilities and mental health conditions.
Underwriters price that. One Georgia agency lists "medically vulnerable passenger transport" among the main reasons NEMT premiums run high. Two exposures stand out.
A wheelchair passenger can be hurt by a hard stop with no other vehicle involved, which leaves no other driver to share the fault. NHTSA's research note on wheelchair users injured in motor vehicle incidents estimated that improper or no securement was involved in 35% of those injuries and deaths, and lift malfunctions in 19%. The estimate is built from hospital emergency department data for 1991 to 1995, so treat the shares as directional, not current.
A more recent University of Michigan study for NHTSA reviewed 74 wheelchair-seated occupants in 69 crash and non-crash events, eight of them sudden braking or turning. Only 78% of the wheelchairs were properly secured, only 38% of the occupants were properly belted, and 33% suffered serious to fatal injuries. The researchers call it a convenience sample, not a representative one, but the pattern is what your underwriter worries about: the strap, the belt and the lift. Our wheelchair securement training guide covers the procedure.
A driver alone with a cognitively impaired rider is an exposure many general liability policies exclude by endorsement (ISO's current forms are CG 40 28 and CG 40 29). Gen Re describes abuse and molestation as "a severity prone exposure" with "the potential for extreme balance sheet implications", and notes that reviver statutes in some states reopen claims long after the statute of limitations would have closed them. Buyers still require it: Arizona's Medicaid agency writes a sexual abuse and molestation requirement of at least $500,000 into its standard subcontract terms for work with children and vulnerable adults. That coverage comes from a specialty market and is priced like one.
Exposure accrues per mile, and an NEMT van runs loaded trips, deadhead miles and standing orders across a full shift. Insurers measure it directly where they can: Progressive's commercial telematics program scores "how much they're driven" alongside how and where.
The limit you buy drives the premium, and brokers set it high. MTM requires $2 million each in auto and general liability from its Missouri providers. Georgia DHS requires a $3 million combined single limit plus a $2 million umbrella for coordinated transportation providers, from an insurer rated A- or better. Those upper layers sit right where nuclear verdicts land, and umbrella was the fastest-rising line in CIAB's Q2 survey. Requirements vary by state and by contract, so pull the insurance exhibit from each one you hold.
A new operator has no loss runs, so underwriters fill the gap with assumptions. Southern States Insurance puts it bluntly: "Carriers price for worst-case." Its June 2026 guide puts a typical new operator's year-one commercial auto at $16,000 to $17,000 per vehicle, against about $7,000 at the low end. That is one agency's quote experience, not a rate filing.
The specialist programs that know this class often want a track record first. Amwins' paratransit and NEMT program asks for three years in business, five units and three years of loss runs. RT Specialty's NEMT workers' comp program requires three years under the same ownership. RLI does target new ventures and hard-to-place fleets, with a $50,000 minimum premium.
Size matters even after year three. Workers' comp states the principle openly: in NCCI's experience rating, "the larger an employer, the more its mod calculation is influenced by its own experience", because one claim can swamp a small employer's record. A three-van fleet's clean year proves little statistically, so your documentation has to do the arguing.
Physical damage claims follow repair prices. The consumer price index for motor vehicle maintenance and repair was up 5.2% in the 12 months to August 2026. AM Best names rising repair costs among the reasons it expects the commercial lines combined ratio to rise in 2026. On an accessible van, a damage claim can involve the ramp or lift and the lowered floor as well as the body, so make sure the conversion is scheduled on the policy, not just the chassis.
The same agency that published the price ranges also renewed two NEMT accounts in one month at $4,000 and $11,000 per vehicle: "They are both doing the exact same thing." The factors it says separate them are operating policies, hiring practices, maintenance, driving records, management experience and claims history. Those are yours.
You cannot control the industry combined ratio or the limits a broker writes into its contract. Shopping helps at the margin. A clean, documented operation helps every year.
Because commercial auto as a whole is unprofitable. The line has lost money for 13 straight years and carriers have raised rates for 55 straight quarters, so clean accounts absorb part of the industry's losses. Commercial auto premiums rose 4.5% in Q2 2026 even as most commercial lines fell.
You carry passengers, many of them elderly or disabled, and underwriters price medically vulnerable riders as a higher-severity exposure. Wheelchair securement and lift injuries can happen without a crash, abuse and molestation coverage is a specialty purchase, and the contracts cited above require $1 million to $3 million in auto liability limits.
Usually not after one year alone. Several specialist programs want three years in business and three years of loss runs, and a small fleet's own record carries limited statistical weight. Clean loss runs, telematics data and documented training are what open more markets over time.
Fewer and smaller claims, from driver selection, securement training and fast incident reporting. Telematics is the lever with a published discount.
Not legal or insurance advice. Requirements and pricing vary by state, carrier and contract; confirm with a licensed agent, your broker contract and your state regulator before you bind coverage.
Insurance, rates and the market behind them land in The NEMTrepreneur Dispatch every Tuesday. Subscribe free.
The NEMT Entrepreneur directory lists 2,000+ non-emergency medical transportation providers by state, city and service type.


